"Suffering" is the most challenging issue that face religions. It directly challenges theism or the religions that believe in God, the unique Almighty the Benevolent the All-powerful, the absolute. In these religious suffering is often considered as a penalty for committing sins; but it is difficult to support this explanation in the face of the suffering of the innocent and the welfare success of the evil. Using a descriptive analytical method, this article seeks to discuss the question of the suffering of the righteous and the welfare of the evil and the answers offered by the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) because the afore mentioned answer seems dusty, on the one hand, and there is a need to address this question, on the other. The righteous suffer for the purpose of purification and divine discipline, accepting the heavy responsibility of the ascension of others, the atonement of the children of Israel or all the peoples of the world, and the test, according to the Old Testament. Sometimes their suffering is due to the sins of their fathers and the welfare of the evil is due to the righteousness of their fathers. One of the views is that the notion of the suffering of the righteous and the welfare of the evil is too difficult for the human intellect to comprehend. It is sometimes said that the suffering befalls the righteous by Divine Decree.
Title :رنج درستکاران و کامیابی شریران و پاسخهای به آن در کتاب مقدس عبری (عهد قدیم)
Abstract:
«رنج» چالش برانگیزترین مسئله در برابر ادیان است. این چالش در برابر خداباوری یا ادیانی که به خدای واحد خیرخواه قادر مطلق اعتقاد دارند، مستقیم است. در این ادیان، اغلب گفته می شود که رنج کیفر گناه است؛ اما دشوار است در برابرِ رنج بی گناهان و کامیابی شریران، از این پاسخ حمایت کرد. به دلیل ناکافی بودن این پاسخ از یک سو، و لزوم پاسخ دادن به این مسئله از سوی دیگر، این مقاله بر آن است که ﺑﺎ روش ﺗﻮﺻﯿﻔﯽ و ﺗﺤﻠﯿﻠﯽ «رنج درستکاران و کامیابی شریران و پاسخ های به آن در کتاب مقدس عبری (عهد قدیم)» را به بحث بگذارد. بنا بر عهد قدیم، درستکاران با هدف تطهیر و تأدیب الهی، تقبّل مسئولیت سنگین عروج دیگران، کفارة بنی اسرائیل یا همة مردم جهان، و امتحان، رنج می کشند.
گاهی نیز رنج آنان به سبب گناهان پدرانشان و کامیابی شریران به دلیل درستکاری پدران آنهاست. همچنین، بنا بر نظرگاهی، رنج درستکاران و کامیابی شریران فراتر از فهم عقل انسان است. گاهی نیز گفته می شود که رنج درستکاران بنا بر تقدیر خداست.
صادقنیا، مهراب و محمدباقر نائیجی، 1394، «کارکردهای تربیتی و اخلاقی رنج در الاهیات یهودی»، پژوهشهای ادیانی، ش6، ص89-116.
قرجالو، داود و محسن جاهد، 1391، «پاسخ سوئینبرن به مسئلة شر»، فلسفه دین، ش12، ص5-36.
یزدانی، عباس، 1388، «ارزیابی پاسخ پلنتینگا به "مسئله شر به مثابه دلیلی علیه وجود خدا"»، قبسات، ش52، ص71-94.
Agus‚ Jacob Bernard, 2007, “Good and Evil”‚ in Encyclopaedia of Judaica‚ Fred Skolnik (editor in chief)‚ New York: Macmillan Reference USA‚ In Association With Keter Publishing House LTD., Jerusalem‚ vol 7‚ p 752-754.
Bemporad‚ Jack‚ 2005, “Suffering”‚ in The Encyclopedia of Religion‚ Lindsay Jones (editor in chief)‚ New York: Macmillan Reference USA‚ vol 14‚ p 8804-8809.
Bertocci‚ Peter A‚ 2005, “Theism”‚ in The Encyclopedia of Religion‚ Lindsay Jones (editor in chief), New York: Macmillan Reference USA‚ vol 13‚ p 9102-9108.
Carr, David M‚ 2010, An introduction to the Old Testament: sacred texts and imperial contexts of the Hebrew Bible, New York: Wiley-Blackwell.
Crenshaw‚ James L, 2005, Defending God: biblical responses to the problem of evil, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fox, Michael V‚ 2004, “Proverbs, Introduction and Annotations” in The Jewish Study Bible, Editors: Adele Berlin and Marc Zvi Brettler, New York: Oxford University Press.
Green‚ Ronald M‚ 2005, “Theodicy”‚ in The Encyclopedia of Religion‚ Lindsay Jones (editor in chief), New York: Macmillan Reference USA‚ vol 13‚ p 9111-9121.
Harris, Stephen L, 2011‚ Understanding the Bible, New York: McGraw-Hill.
Harris, Stephen L. and Platzner, Robert L, 2008‚ The Old Testament: an introduction to the Hebrew Bible, New York: McGraw-Hill.
Karesh, Sara E., Hurvitz, Mitchell M, 2006, Encyclopedia of Judaism, New York: Infobase Publishing.
Karff‚ Rabbi Samual E; Goldenberg‚ Robert‚ 1993, “Judaism”‚ in Religions of the World‚ Forman‚ Robert K. C (general editor), New York: ST. Martin’s Press.
Kilpatrick‚ T. B, 1921‚ “Suffering”‚ in The Encyclopaedia of Religion and Ethics‚ James Hastings (editor)‚ New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons‚ vol 12‚ p 1-10.
Lange‚ Nicholas de‚ 2002, An Introduction to Judaism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Levinson, Bernard M, 2004‚ “Deuteronomy, Introduction and Annotations” in The Jewish Study Bible, Editors: Adele Berlin and Marc Zvi Brettler, New York: Oxford University Press.
Morrison, Martha A., Brown, Stephen F, 2009‚ Judaism, New York: Infobase Publishing.
Neusner, Jacob‚ 2006, Judaism: the basics, London and New York: Routledge.
Noss‚ John B, 1955‚ Man’s Religions, New York: The Macmillan Company‚ Tenth Printing.
Peake, Arthur S, 1947‚ The Problem of Suffering in the Old Testament‚ London: The Epworth Press (Edgar C. Barton).
Pirkei Avos Synthesized The Chapters of the Fathers With Inspiring and Integrated Elucidations Based on Traditional Jewish Commentaries & The Rosh’s Orchos Chayim the Pathways to Life‚ With a Special Addition of All 613 Commandments in Prose Accurately Following the Rambam’s Seminal “Sefer Hamitzvos”‚ 2014, Translated and Compiled by Reuven Brauner‚ 18 Rechov Shwartz, Raanana, Israel.
Rabinowitz‚ Louis Isaac, 2007, “Reward and Punishment”‚ in Encyclopaedia of Judaica‚ Fred Skolnik (editor in chief)‚ New York: Macmillan Reference USA‚ In Association With Keter Publishing House LTD., Jerusalem‚ vol 17‚ p 269-270.
Schmitt, Elmer William John‚ 1943, Sin and forgiveness in the Old Testament‚ A Thesis Submitted to the Division of Bible in Drew Theological Seminary of Drew University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy‚ Major Professor: Dr. John Paterson, Madison, New Jersey.
Schwarzschild‚ Steven S, 2007, “Suffering”‚ in Encyclopaedia of Judaica‚ Fred Skolnik (editor in chief)‚ New York: Macmillan Reference USA‚ In Association With Keter Publishing House LTD., Jerusalem‚ vol 19‚ p 291-292.
Weinfeld‚ Moshe‚ 1987, “Israelite Religion”‚ in The Encyclopedia of Religion‚ Mircea Eliade (editor in chief), New York: Macmillan Publish Ing Co; Londan: Collier Macmillan Publishers‚ vol 7‚ p 481-497.
ahmadtobi, Mazaher.(2024) The Suffering of the Righteous and the Welfare of the Evil in the Light of the Answers of the Hebrew Bible (the Old Testament). Ma`rifat-e Adyan, 11(4), 87-104
Mazaher ahmadtobi."The Suffering of the Righteous and the Welfare of the Evil in the Light of the Answers of the Hebrew Bible (the Old Testament)". Ma`rifat-e Adyan, 11, 4, 2024, 87-104
ahmadtobi, M.(2024) 'The Suffering of the Righteous and the Welfare of the Evil in the Light of the Answers of the Hebrew Bible (the Old Testament)', Ma`rifat-e Adyan, 11(4), pp. 87-104
ahmadtobi, M. The Suffering of the Righteous and the Welfare of the Evil in the Light of the Answers of the Hebrew Bible (the Old Testament). Ma`rifat-e Adyan, 2024; 11(4): 87-104